Honestly speaking, there is truly no specific approach to rate a specific cigar simply because of the fact that a cigar can taste different to various smokers as well as different to the same smoker at varied times. People have one of a kind taste so there is really no exact answer to that question. But for the sake of reviewing a given kind of cigar, Cigar Reviews strive hard to provide as accurate as possible the experience, the quality, and the experience that can be expected from the specific type of cigar being reviewed.
There is certainly different facets to take into consideration when rating a cigar. To start with is the consistency of tobacco and the quality of manufacture. Generally, cigars are hand-made and different rollers have different levels of skill. Which means that workers who work 8 hours all day long rolling a cigar will surely make better cigars than the others. Also, one other thing to consider is that tobacco leaves, even when they originate from the same farm, can still differ. Like wine, every harvest may differ from the past harvest. With cigars, it will sometimes be incredible if a selected cigar brand can regularly create a relative higher level of quality year in year out.
An outstanding point in rating a cigar in most cigar review site is the storing and aging of cigars. To generate top quality cigars, it is necessary that proper care of finished cigars is managed. Improper handling and storage can break down its quality therefore it won't provide you with the original sensation, flavor and experience it is suppose to bring to smokers once placed on humidors. With this, when a cigar enthusiast smokes this cigar and then writes a review about it, then expect it to have a poor rating considering the outside factors that impacted the cigar's quality.
So how is cigar rated? Well, it is challenging to throw a moving target especially if you are moving too. It is hard to rate a cigar if your taste buds are numb or when the cigar is manufactured under different conditions and aged at different periods of times.
To summarize, an excellent to do to supply the most accurate cigar review is to invest hard work in acquiring a single cigar brand, make sure that your taste buds are in good condition, enjoy and experience the sensation it really brings and that's when a review should be written. Next thing is to get another brand, smoke it, and do the same process. But it's not just the things that must be considered though good enough idea on how cigars should be rated.